October 31, 2011

Podcast: The X-Factor Season 1 – Top 17 Week

Written by:
Sign up to receive all the latest X Factor Music, News, Rumors and Updates.

Listen to the podcast

Episode 26 direct download

Subscribe to podcast on iTunes

The X-Factor, from its first audition episode, was full of flash and bombast. Everything was big! This didn’t prepare us for the over-the-top production values found in the first live show, which featured floor-to-ceiling monitors, a transparent stage with flashing lights, smoke machines and a small army of backup dancers. The only thing missing from the spectacle was pyrotechnics. It made an impression, but we’re not convinced it was necessary to be flashier than American Idol. In the end, it came down to the performances whose quality was independent of the special effects employed throughout the evening.

Indeed, stripped down performances made for some of the best moments in the show. Josh Krajcik gave a soul-stirring performance of “Forever Young,” eschewing instrumentation in favor of a controlled vocal tone that rang out and filled the room. Drew followed suit with a low-key arrangement of “What a Feeling” carried by the haunting qualities of her voice. Both contestants established themselves as strong contenders for America’s vote and the five million dollar record contract. Leroy Bell did things his own way when singing “Nobody Knows.” Even though it’s not a song best suited for his artistic style, Leroy ran with it and let his charisma and smooth, intense voice carry the song, showing how his past experience as a song writer and an indie performer will turn him into a dark horse for this competition. He doesn’t have a lot of buzz behind him, but he’s one of our favorites and the comments we find for him are very positive.

This is not to say that flashy and fun performances didn’t have merit. Brian “Astro” Bradley’s opening hip-hop mashup of “Rump Shaker” and “Jump” demonstrated his rapping prowess, spitting forth rhymes and rhythms in quick machine-gun bursts. Even with multiple re-watches we are in awe of his ability as a hip-hop MC. InTENsity and the Stereo Hogzz, while having issues in each of their respective performances, were fun to watch and showed that Paula Abdul can and will take the groups category in a positive and constructive direction.

Some performances have us worried. Chris Rene, Rachel Crow and Melanie Amaro all had some problems in their songs with vocal issues creeping in during important moments. We’re the least worried with Melanie Amaro, as it appeared that nerves got the better of her due in no small part to the mind games Simon Cowell has played with her. If she knocks it out of the park on the next show she’ll be fine. As for Chris Rene, the song highlighted his limited range and downplayed his smooth R&B flow, which is the opposite of what we think L.A. Reid would want from him. He needs a song that recalls the moments from his audition or his fan-base will dwindle in the coming weeks. Rachel Crow was the most controversial performance for us. The judges and many online fans loved it, but we didn’t like the song choice and heard multiple vocal errors in the verses of the mashup. Simon is placing her in this child performer box that she is going to outgrow in one or two years, which is a dangerous place to put her.

The eliminations were the correct choices as they consisted of the poorest performances of the night. Dexter, Simone, Phillip and Tiah all had over-wrought set concepts and backup dancers coupled with sub-par vocal performances. We actually enjoyed the Brewer Boys, but since the groups category had an even level of quality it was hard to argue for another group to leave. We would have sent Lakoda Rayne packing because of our music preferences and distaste for their pop country aesthetic which still feels uncomfortable on them. We’re not upset about any of the losses from the first live show.

We’re curious how America will take to the remaining contestants. Who will America love? Who will the fanbase hate? It’s up in the air and gleaning information from the internet buzz will only get you so far. The upcoming week of live shows should prove interesting!

Please let us know your thoughts by dropping us a comment here after listening either here! We love to hear feedback and what you thought of the show. We also encourage you to check out our blog or twitter feed to keep up to date with us!

Episode Length: 34:34

Time Stamps
0:00 – Introduction: Our thoughts on the live show stage and production and Steve Jones
4:23 – Eliminations: Phillip Lomax, The Brewer Boys, Dexter Haygood, Simone Battle and Tiah Tolliver
12:27 – The performances we loved: Brian “Astro” Bradley, Leroy Bell, Josh Krajcik and Drew
19:05 – The performances we didn’t like: Chris Rene, Marcus Canty and Lakoda Rayne
23:51 – Controversial/Lukewarm performances: The Stereo Hogzz, InTENsity, Stacy Francis, Rachel Crow and Melanie Amaro
32:24 – Wrap-up

Be Sociable, Share!
  • Tags:

    Look for similar articles under these categories: 

    2 responses to "Podcast: The X-Factor Season 1 – Top 17 Week"

    1. # DJ commented on November 2nd, 2011:

      Hello great podcast and I agree with most of what you guys said except Marcus. Marcus without question is the best guy vocally in his category. He’s a great performer in my opinion and he made the song work for him. Strange song choice, but you have to applaud him for not making it a total disaster like other contestants would’ve if they were given that song.

      I agree with your thoughts about Rachel. She really does well on the high notes, but on the low notes she struggles and it shows. I really don’t don’t think she should’ve gone through, I see the potential she has now and if she would’ve just waited a few years to try out, her voice would’ve matured and she would’ve been amazing. I think Tiah should’ve been kept over Rachel. I agree with everyone they sent home except Tiah, she could’ve brought a lot to this competition.

      I think overall this is a strong group of contestants, and it’ll be interesting to see how votes go. If this was Idol I could pretty much tell you how voting would go. I think this show because it features more r&b and hip hop, it could bring in a whole different audience or it could be the same ppl who vote on Idol. Anyway great podcast one again.

    2. # James G commented on November 2nd, 2011:

      Hi DJ, thanks for listening to our podcast!

      I agree with your comments with regard to Marcus Canty’s vocals as he does have the strongest voice in the boys category (definitely stronger than Chris Rene and you can’t really compare with Astro, since he’s doing something completely different). We liked what Marcus did during the judges’ houses portion of the category, in particular because it showed off aspects of his vocals that we hadn’t heard before. As for his performance last week, I think it’s subjective preference for us. We’re not connecting with what he’s doing, for whatever reason. He uses the stage and he, as you mentioned, made the song into something that worked for him. So I can’t fault him there. I would like him to resist the urge to sing towards the floor, but that’s more of a directors note. So yeah, I guess I’ll have to chalk this up to personal taste. I definitely can see why lots of other people like him though, even if it’s not my thing.

      I agree with you about Rachel. She’s just not vocally ready yet and with her being in the transition between being a girl and becoming an adult she’s at the mercy of how Simon Cowell wants to create her image, and he seems to want to play up her youth. Tiah could have been interesting, although I imagine she would have gone home in the first or second week of voting. The general attitude towards her on Twitter, Youtube videos, blogs, etc was negative. I didn’t agree with a lot of what was said there, but I don’t think America warmed to her.

      I’m excited to see what the voting block is like for this show. I’m hoping for it to be different from Idol to shake things up a bit.

      Thanks for the comment!

    Top - Home